TV & Radio

Why Credit Card Rate Caps Cut Off the Borrowers They Target

Patrick M. Brenner tells Tim Jones and Chris Arps why a 10% credit card rate cap would move credit away from subprime borrowers, and what the permitting bill, the Corner Post ruling and the NAIC mean for consumers.

Aired onNewsTalk STLNovember 12, 2026

Patrick M. Brenner, President and CEO of the Southwest Public Policy Institute (SPPI), joined hosts Tim Jones and Chris Arps on NewsTalk STL to discuss credit card rate caps, the Senate permitting bill, the fight over debit card fees and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

Brenner began with a New York Fed study finding that a rate cap moves credit toward prime borrowers and away from subprime and deep-subprime ones. He said Trump, Sanders, Hawley, Ocasio-Cortez and Luna share the premise behind a 10% credit card cap, expected a renewed push if Sen. Elizabeth Warren chairs the Senate Banking Committee and doubted that any temporary cap would stay temporary. Asked about default rates, he showed how a $7 charge on a one-week, $100 loan works out to an APR of roughly 365 percent, and called a rate cap a price control.

On the permitting bill, Brenner pointed listeners to Gregory A. Schroeder’s letter in The Washington Post and said its transmission title moves three decisions from the states to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission — where the lines run, whose land they take and who pays — with a federal permit that carries the power to condemn private land.

He then turned to the Eighth Circuit’s Corner Post ruling vacating the Federal Reserve’s debit card fee cap and the Linney’s Pizza case in the Sixth Circuit, which he said could send the question to the Supreme Court. He closed on the NAIC: not a federal regulator but a 501(c)(3) that does not disclose what its executives are paid.

Read SPPI’s op-ed on the left-right push for rate caps.

About the guest

Patrick M. Brenner is President and CEO of the Southwest Public Policy Institute.