The Southwest Public Policy Institute filed comments with the Surface Transportation Board on November 18, 2026, in Docket No. FD 36873, supporting the Revised Application of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern. The combination would give American shippers single-line transcontinental rail service for the first time, and the applicants project it would shift about 2.1 million truckloads a year from highways to rail and save shippers about $3.5 billion annually.
The comments argue that the applicants have met the Board’s heightened standard for major mergers. Their commitments, including expanded Committed Gateway Pricing, an Open Gateway Commitment, protections for shippers going from three carriers to two and from two to one, temporary access to alternative service if service declines, and a rate relief process, are enforceable promises aimed at the very harms opponents allege.
Drawing on a new paper by Professor Donald J. Kochan of the Antonin Scalia Law School, and on SPPI’s policy brief Consider the Source When Rival Railroads Object, the comments explain why the loudest objections deserve the least weight. A rival railroad gains when a merger raises rates or degrades service, and loses when it lowers costs and improves service, so its opposition is a sign the merger would help shippers. Economists, courts and four former senior antitrust enforcers in this docket have said the same. Canadian National’s opposition, which ended in a settlement paid in terminal and track interests, shows how negotiable such objections are.
SPPI asks the Board to:
- Approve the Revised Application with the applicants’ commitments as enforceable conditions.
- Weigh competing railroads’ filings as advocacy, crediting their claims only where they rest on data the Board can test.
- Decline conditions that serve rivals rather than shippers.
- Hold the schedule, without further extensions sought by the applicants’ competitors.
SPPI first made the case for the merger in October in Diesel Is Driving the Affordability Debate. A Rail Merger Could Help.
